◆ School & College Decision Advisory
Should this family commit to School A — before the fee deadline?
A family relocating to Dehradun asked us to compare two shortlisted schools (here A and B) for a child moving into secondary school. Names and identifying details are redacted; the structure and language are exactly what a real report uses.
How to read this report
Every statement is labelled by what kind of thing it is — verified, observed, or our judgment. Tap a label to see only findings of that type.
The decision, in the client’s words
- A calm, structured academic environment over a high-pressure one
- A manageable daily commute (under 40 minutes each way)
- Real support for a child who is strong verbally but anxious in exams
- Full transparency on fees — no surprises after admission
- A decision made before the next term’s fee deadline
Option comparison
What we found — labelled by evidence type
Both schools’ board affiliation and current class sizes were confirmed directly from official records. School A: ~28 per class. School B: ~34 per class.
On a working-day visit, School A’s morning drop-off cleared within 15 minutes; School B’s approach road (via ██████) was single-lane and congested past 8:15am.
The lane leading to School B floods to roughly ankle depth for about two weeks at peak monsoon, per three separate local residents.
Given the child’s exam anxiety and verbal strength, School A’s smaller classes and named counselling lead appear the stronger structural fit — though fit is a judgment, not a fact.
School B’s marketing states a “1:12 mentor ratio.” This could not be independently verified and was not evidenced on site. Treat as unconfirmed until shown in writing.
School A’s published fee schedule omits transport and a mandatory annual “development” charge that two current parents described. Budget could exceed the quoted figure by a meaningful margin.
Shortlist School A, but make the offer conditional on a written, all-inclusive fee schedule. Re-drive the School B route once during monsoon before ruling it out on access alone.
No findings of that type in this report.
Assumption & risk register
Questions to put in writing
- Please share a single, all-inclusive annual fee schedule in writing, including transport and any development or one-time charges.
- What is the actual current teacher-to-student ratio, by class, this term?
- Who is the named counselling lead, and what is the exam-support process for an anxious student?
- What is the school’s contingency for monsoon-season access and attendance?
Recommended next steps
- Request the written fee schedule from School A before paying any deposit.
- Do one monsoon-time drive to School B at 8:00am on a weekday.
- Confirm School B’s ratio claim in writing, or set it aside.
- Book a follow-up consultation once the written fees arrive — we’ll finalise the recommendation.
Validated by five independent lenses.
The Education advisor led the review; Legal & Risk, Administrative, Travel & Logistics, and Corporate lenses cross-checked it. Client identity was withheld from the panel throughout.
This is what your decision could look like.
Book a consultation — no account needed.